First of all, ni pengumuman yang korang tak dapat layamn kat TV semalam ketika konsert pertama semalam.
Of course ni menjawab misteri ke mana Zana menhghilang dan betul ke dia menarik diri, dan atas sebab apa.
Officially, of course you guys know konon she withdrew because of stress, and dia minta...kan?
Ni the actual slightly longer story.
Khamis, si Zana sudahpun membuat permintaan nak tarik diri daripada Akademi Fantasia. Walaupun banyak kali dia di minta reconsider, she mati mati nak tarik diri.
Adakah ini berkaitan isu gambar bogel yang didakwa miliknya?
Pihak Akademi mengaku mereka ada memaklumkan Zana mengenai apa yang berlaku kat luar (silly) dan oleh kerana itu (they didn't say if this was the total fault, or only part of the reason) she withdrew.
Alkisahnya juga, Thursday setelah Zana keluar dari Akademi, Jumaat Zana juga telah membuat laporan polis mengenai pengedaran gambar yang di dakwa gambar dia bogel.
So kes dia ni skang kes polis.
Now on to the concert after all that drama (tapi you have to ask yourself so many questions still kan)
Pada sapa yang menonton, sesungguhnya korang tatau beta[a terkejutnya kami  yang dalam dewan sebab letopan pyro tanpa warning
As the evening progressed baru kita paham keperluan meka nak memekakkan kami kat Dewan Sivik ngan letupan letupan....kalao tak banyak agik kesumbangan aku terpaksa layan.
The stage and backdrop looks better, with a more all out feel towards the colous, though you have to wonder why they chose so considering they wanted a more reddish glow to it. Weird cocktail of colours.
Seterusmnya masuk fashion show untuk memuaskan hati sponsors mana sekor-sekor pelajar nak parade catwalk dan tayang baju. At least elok ler sikit tanpa Yoda tahun ni.
Still, takde umphhh dalam meka wat camtuh dari perkenalan setiap pelajar traditionally.
Selepas itu masuk perkenalan pengkritik lak.
Fauziah Latiff? My God! She can't even sing anymore, and apa lak nak ciplak branding Malaysian Idol lagik! Baik panggil Paul Moss terus.
Hattan ok aa...puas ati gak, and last but not least, Ogy, which I suppose in unarguable. In fact, both of them je da cukup, cause the third person is such a non-contributing waste of time.
By the way kalau biasa aku wat rating berapa bintang bebudak dapat tuk persembahankat konsert....musim ni sebab busuk sangat, aku nak hadiahkan toilet plunger atau beros jamban terus kalau their performance nih BUSUK! Which covers a lot of them for this week actually.

Afiq - Janjiku (Sofaz)
He started out what sounded like way too low, and it was barely audible.
It was painful with his voice mendatar saja, and hitting the wrong note here and there.
In fact, he was the first one of the night yang seolah terlupa lak meolody for the first verse. By the end of that baru nak pick up and show some promise, when again he seem to lose his way.
All in all cam malam karaoke kat memana warung kat Putrajaya. Oh and again, aku tak paham the need for backing vocals kalau langsong tak dengar habok, atau bila dengar pon memang tak perlu sangat.
Jee kata dia ada style. Mak aih...bergunanya dia....aku rasa dia masih ingat dia Paula Abdul kot. Hattan was more accurate when he said bukak mulut je sumbang while Ogy hit the nail on the head, when she commented on the lack of penghayatan on the performance, not to mention lack of understanding of the lyrics, for some reason which seems to be the theme for the night.
Hope this guy goes out early cause berangan dia melebihi bakat dia yang setakat ni nampak ciput sangat by comparison.
For some reason, he seems to think he's Usher (merasalah muka ko sesuai usher panggung wayang jer).
I officially nickname Aziq, POYO making him the first nak dapat nama timangan sebab da masuk blacklist aku of those yang patut disepak trajang kuar dari Akademi Fantasia daripada terus menYUJMBANG bukan sahaja lagu tapi juga pada pencemaran bunyi dan pemandangan di sekitar Dewan Sivik dan juga pada slot kemunculannya di Astro Ria.
Urghhh!!!!!!!
 (atas dasar kepoyoan dia tolak agik kalau leh tuk Caya Beb ker haper tagline dia)

Mila - Bersamamu (Siti Sarah)
Sebab yang lain azab sangat, Mila sounded better...at least untuk sebaris dua then kesengauan dia take over for the end of the verse.
From that point on, dia join geng lain dalam bersama berlawan tuk piala SUMBANGsih for the night...aku taka paham tol.
Meka nih tone deaf ke? So much for trying to be professionals, sampai memegang mic pun cam nak telan...
Komen pengkritik? Jee ngan statement recycle of the year from Malaysian Idol, "nervous ke?" was again, so tak perlu. But if you thought that was as good as she got, how how tetiba nak puji mata..haiyooo!!! NO NEED SANGAT!
Hattan gave his best line of the night - "banyak sangat apartment...asik flat flat flat je..."
I like!
As for Ogy, let's face it, dia sorang je yang bebetul comprehensive dari segi segala pemerhatian dia.Point by point...bagus tegur pasal signal hand Karam Singh Walia nya yang tak perlu pun obvious point which wasn't raised by the others.
for potential but nothing more

Dafi - Uptown Girl (Westlife)
Yes, again another outing at amateur karaoke night.
Apa tujuan dua orang membadutkan diri in Ebi dan si poyo Afiq tuh by playing stupid clowns up to bad acting nih??!!
Yang tiga orang lak in yang buang masa... Rizal, and Farha memamg tak perlu tambah menYUMBANGkan suara.
Harap jambu, sora mendatar ala ala runway KLIA.
No dynamics, no use of range at all and generally no hope tol sora ciut dia tuh.
And by the way, yang patutnya Uptown Girl tuh cam Downtown Streetwalker
Persembahan camtuh dapat paling banyak undi for the night?
You've got to be joking...
As for the critics, did we expect anything more bila Jee komen pada senyuman lak?
And were we surprised when Jee kata penyampaian bagus.
Kalau ikut standard Jee and we know how well she's doing lately...I suppose it's more than expected of her.
Hattan lawak tol...kata Dafi ketar the moment nak pegang pompuan sebab tak biasa. I wonder how true that is.And Ogy? Hit the nail on the head as usual.

Diya - Aku Masih Setia (Dia Fadila)
Gediks and watse of time...bantal mana?
Nak tidur tol....tapi kata Jee "Ko ada pakej"...how original!!!! We didn't hear that in Idol!
Hattan and Ogy again the only realistic ones for the night, with Ogy punya laser paling berasap punya, "setakat maintain cantik tuh betul....tapi cantik pun bukan cantik sangat".

Farha - Pemuzik Jalanan (Search)
Persembahan yang very the ala ajaran sesat Ayah Pin yang kemudian melalak flat. Rock tuh setakat menjerit ke?
Pastu badut perempuan lak masuk....aduih...Dekna tuh mengingatkan aku pada Mas tul.
Sakit...sora paling menyakitkan sepanjang malam. Ni cam kutip rempit depan Dean Sivik masuk last minute jer....takde rupa ada preparation langsung!.
And what's with the jpget lambak cam hanjeng gila tuh????
Arghhh!!! Stress tol show cipan camnih. Segmen membodohkan bebudak je keja bab nih (but then again, I think that's the only thing the kids are doing SO well.
Mai kita komen Jee yang begitu kritikal "Saya suka suara Farha" (apa yang dia tak suka?)
Hattan kata mamat nih  rock jadian, "Vocal awak takde character tuk rock".
Again true, simple things like understanding the genre nak perform pun tak reti. Wat malu depan rocker cam Hattan jer.
Ogy pun kata separuh masak punya rock singer

 

Ebi - Milik Siapakah Gadis Ini (Sudirman)
Banyak sangat masalah dia nih. Tempo pun takleh like the rest...not to mention pitching...oops...sama je rupanya ngan stok stok lain sebelom nih.
Tapi tone dia sedap, cuma aku tak paham dia ni tak belajar apa apa pasal vocal control ke.
Molot tuh cam kunyah gula getah. None of his voice yang keluar leh pakai.
I think he needs to do more bubbling and yawning and much more facial exercises...cikgu Syafi? Maki sikit...!
And tangan dia tuh kenapa...nak mintak sedekah ke asik hulur sana sini.
Part ni yang Jee tetiba komen lebih (kena tegur pihak production ke?)
Nak mintak drama katanya. Takde lak puji mata ker...idung ke...baju ke yang cantik? Tak taste ek?
Hattan pointed out about Ebi not opening his mouth. while Ogy marah pasal penghayatan lagu yang patutnya ala tengah skodeng pompuan.
Aduh...pecah perot!

Dekna - Tanpamu (Farahwahida)
Terasa bosan jika trus aku nak dengar dia. Mas jugak rupanya...versi Erra Fazira yang eyebags overdose dan berangan. Sumbang, flat blah blah blah...everything....
Malas nak repeat bebenda sama. Memang betul ler musim ni bebudak ni semua feeling je overdose.
Speaking of overdose, si poyo Afiq tuh kenapa???
Matilah ko kalaiu setakat backing nak overdose...ingat Zahid ke? Perut tuh cover sikit kalau da pakai sendat tuh terkeluar segalanya tapi feeling six pack.
Apparently bukan aku sorang je ingat dia cam Mas...even Aznil had to share that comment.
But in true fashion, Jee :kata rupa dia leh menagkap minat orang. For all the promises Jee seems to think she holds I wonder if I have the wrong show and this is kind of clown school rather than anything else.
But trust her judgement kan...even Hattan pun kata memula masuk je da sumbang..."ari ni saya frust sebab semua vocal ke laut"
Bukan ke laut je...you're all the way to the Antartica and freaking back!
Merasalah Ted nak menyampuk ata janji jadik duta Mamee Slurp!
I think Ogy was the only one to feel the vibe or lack of when she said performance Deka adalah persembahan paling malas.
 (sebab ada poyo overdose)

Shawal - Harapan (Fazley Zainal)
I love his tone dan walaupon dia struggle, tak kisah la sakit ke tak, he didn't do as bad as the others.
Kira takyah bagik discount sebab keadaan kesihatan dia tetap dia keep up. No excuses and he did have massive pitching problems, but I think among budak laki semua tone dia yang paling rounded, firm and weighty. Promising is the word.
Walaopon baju cam 80an dan rambut cam bersanggul lak bahagian belakang.
Mai kita ramai ramai salahkan Yoda dan team wardrobe.
Jee at this point got her momentary delusional whim to play intelligent katanya tetiba analytical when Hattan sendiri admit about his tone and his potential and Ogy felt the same, walaupon maki sebakul dulu sampai si Dollah Cantk yang floor manager pun kena.

Candy - Kaching (Shania Twain)
I don't even know whay that was. but I think she can be better as something else if not a singer kalao ikut gaya.
I don't know if she had a problem with English sangat (tanya cikgu suka p-ink tuh) but tak paham haram sepatah pon.
Of course we expect Jee to like this, while Hattan and Ogy just shrugged at the language problems.
Honestly she has a half decent voice, but tunggu dan lihat camna lak pasnih sebab honestly hara, sepatah pon aku tak paham what she was wailing about.
The best dressed for the night, and at least she looked like a popstar compared to the others.
The one time Jasmi Rejab justified his pay cheque with Astro.
Merasalah out of 13 onstage, you have to at least get one right!



Rizal - Menanti Sebuah Jawaban (Padi)
He killed one of my favourite songs. Dia cam kelas belajar membaca bukan menyanyi for some reason sebab dia nyanyi takde flow langsung...sepatah...sepatah...sepatah....
Harapkan muka jer....one word, MELODY!
Or maybe cikgu bahasa Inggeris meka ni lom ajar kot the meaning of the word because he sure as hell didn't display even the basic understanding of adhering to the melody and the tune of the song..
Lack of dynamics and application of the range of his vocals, if any sebab aku rasa antara budak budak laki dia paling hampeh stakat nih.
Easily one of the WORST performances of the night.
terkejut lak Jee tak taste dan katakan "quite mendukacitakan"
Hattan pun geleng pala while the surprise cam in the only statement from Ogy yang aku tak agree with at all.
Hai...Dekna kena pedas sangat tapi hanya kerana hunky dory in Ogy's eyes kot dia leh terlepas.

Noni - Tak Ada Logika (Agnes Monica)
Ni Agnes Monica ke Elyana. Heh!!! Baju cam...erm....
Anyway ni sekor agik dak pompuan yang gedik lebih..
Maybe it was the pathetic outdated 80s choreography, and then dia semput, but somehow it was a weird key she started with, and for some reason it didn't sound right.
If nothing else teringat lak persembahan Mas ketika Kylie Minogue punya lagu. Ni just one notch better, which is nothing nice to say ok.
Backing vocal pon ancus...and what's with the music outro? Walaupon ada bunga api, namun tuh tak cukup nak kaburkan my sight for how truly horrendous it was.
The worst of the girls, setanding ngan Rizal. I mean seriously, an easy pop meloody pun takleh hold...
Kata Jee? "Saya suka..."....you would...(tak serik agik ke?)
Hattanaku rasa wish the earth would swallow him while Ogy regains her form and said "HANCUQQQQ!!!" adding that even the backing dancers were better.



Heliza - Kau Pergi Jua (Adam Ahmad)
Seperti sudah di agak, she delivered even though the end of the first verse flat sikit.
Styling memang Siti tapi selepas berdarah telinga satu malam, aku rasa ok ler sikit in comparison. I didn't like the music for this one, sebab berlawan ngan vocal dia lak...maybe it was just the house mix.
Why was she dressed cam katil Dekna lak ngan ropol ropol whatever frills yang pink tuh. Aiyo!! Ada je tak betul kan konsert pertama ni.
Shaky on low notes but at least dia ada ler initiative nak main lenggok, and her improv for a first week effort jauh bagai langit dan bumi kalau banding dak yang lain.
I don't even care wat Jee, Hattan dam Ogy was Heliza was easily the best of the night. Tul Hattan cakap pasal vibrato dan uniqueness of her approach which kureng from the others. Ogy on her delivery of expression agreeable too.
But this was the only one my part of the hall applauded for.

After the stupid long break sebab panjang sangat show (tu akibatnya kalao nak ramai sangat peserta), we had to put up with the drama of Aswad's stupid video clip.
Aiyo....come on lah...there are a million and one rempit souding freaks who can play rock wannabe..., apa lak nih. Agenda Astro ler tuh nak main emosi tuk galakkan undi simpati nih.
And then si Aznil indulged in his little whim nak nyanyi lagu BPR tugasan Aswad.
Rating tuk Aswad?
 
Hanya kerana aku memang nyampah ngan this whole sympathy game dan memberi dia peluang and all. Aznil tak dapat rating....sorry ek..sebab dia bukan bertanding.dan aku tension sikit sebab dia memanjangkan agik show dan cam conquer sangat the stage when the spotlight was actually supposed to be on the kids.


'Kejutan' kedua selepas tak announce Zana ketika show (da perasan actually mula mula sebab kami kira 13 kerusi je) Fatin kuar mengejut dan wat show.
Does anybody else think this girl is like the poster girl for anorexia? Somebody feed her please! I hardly think this is positive nak bagi budak budak skang think that being a stick insect is normal. Aku rasa sebelah sorang tuh, she's be a perfect 10. She's the 1 dan the other's the 0.
Her performance?
Haiyoo...I have to say kalao ikutkan, she sounds better dari segi tanpa preparation than most of the others.
BUT!!! Apart from dangdut apa lagik dia mampu buat? Sengau, nipis dan tak bermaya sora dia....waste of time.
Jee mangkuk tol...orang masalah kesihatan kulit, ni lak dia kata leh affect sora. Mangkuk jamban tol...get your facts ler sebelom komen. Apa da...nampak sangat wat homework.
Hattan pun cam tak caya dia sakit sampai leh affect and Ogy pun tak kuasa nak komen lebih.
But frnakly I think she's overrated tol considering dak ni dangdut bak pesen rock. BOSAN!
Mai kita nyanyi ramai ramai..."aku bosan...bosan...dengan dirimu...aku benci...benci..."

And last but not least, Menuju Puncak.
Selain pakaian meka yang BUSUK...the new arrangement of Menuju Puncak tak menaikkan smangat langsung and is DEFINITELY THE BIGGEST LOSER MOMENT in the history of Akademi Fantasia.
Not to mention baju bebudak busuk!!!! Nampak sponsored by Girodano ke kedai pakaian Hari Hari jer. And the steps...mmm..kesian lak Linda Jasmine kena ikut arrangement busuk tuh.
For the massacre of Menujuk Puncak, aku bagik

For bebudak semua, aku bagik tepukan gemuruh because their timing and execution of steps ok gak ler walaopon tak perfect.
Their vocals weren't all that bad for a first week and most of them did better than their individual shows.
Still, it is a shame to the branding of Akademi Fantasia, and the new production team has managed to screw up every single aspect of the show, sampai lagu tema pun cam sampah!
Kembali kan Akademi Fantasia!!! NOW!
So many problems....that no one even gave a flying fish about Diya kena sepak trajang kuar (nangis overdose lebih daripada any other first concert in Akaemi Fantasia history ok!)
Mana Roslan Aziz kata nak campak beg halau berambos? Mana tampar tiga kalinya? Huh...
Memula kata bebudak ni semua power...kita da tengok betapa 'power' meka ni.
Then kata tamao menangis...and of course...we saw what happened last night.
So? Musim kelima ni tahap sampah...and any true Akademi Fantasia fan will admit that.
So boo to all of you who screwed up the show we all love and now just love to hate all the more.
Kalau nak identify the problems semalam...banyak sangat, tapi nih some of the main that I found. I'm not going to state about budak budak ampehs tuh semua yang sumbang abih...because that's pretty obvius da.
So production team...kalau nak take notes, please jot down these points.
1)Music arrangement was horrible! Cam gi Red Box karaoke (actually tuh kira ok agik..cam karaoke murahan mana la sebenarnya) the music arrangement semalam.
I know the kids sucked...but the music didn't help.
2)Elements that made the show were eliminated.Like the intro ketika muzik latar Menuju Puncak. That's a tradition...and sacred...you don't get rid of that! That stupid fashion show was so plugging the sponsors its not even funny.
3)Choreograhy was horrible (tapi aku tak salahkan Linda Jasmine 100% because she had to work with the horrible arrangement)
4)I think Aznil is still the best host ever...but the programme is not Akademi Fantasia Aznil, so spotlight dia takleh grab from the kids sangat.
5)Get rid of Jee.Hattan dan Ogy pun da cukup.Dahler Roslan Aziz ada...ni nak dia lak...baik terus amik Paul Moss and you call this Fantasia Idol. Bangap...
6)Gimik murahan konon bebudak tuh dihantarbalik kampung terus blah blah blah...doesn't work kalao bagik 10 minit nak turun pentas nak nangis bagi banjir. Weird tol!
7)Don't touch Menuju Puncak if you can't make it better. Because no matter how bad the show is, Menuju Puncak tak penah disappoint camtuh. And it did this time.
8)Please get  Jasmi Rejab to do his work.
9)Stop playing up on Aswad and Fatin to get them sympathy votes...pathetic.
10)Cut short the performances and time wasting stuff kalau da tau ramai sangat bebudak.
11)No cheap ass devices like nak eliminate dua pastu tarik balik sebab Zana da out. That was just stupid.
12)Buang pakar motivasi Dr Luuuuuurrvveee kalao sendiri tak mampu contain the situation.
13)While you're at it, the English teacher should go to sebab I don't see his function there at all.
14)Benarkan setiap member of the faculty do their job. Abang Adnan, Syafi, Linda and Fati. This is not Akademi Fantasia Roslan Aziz either sampai semua dia ada say sampai veto power.
15)Tak memaparkan undian kat Dewan is just stupid...and a lousy attempt nak orang emo when people could hardly care less and just want to know for the sake of curiosity.
16)Even music sedih yang biasa main ketika penyingkiran tuh BOSAN! And what's with hauling the bag onstage? That's just cheap kalao musim musim sebelom ni mampu meka wat beg tu muncul dari belakang pentas..dari perut pentas etc.
17)ARRANGEMENTS ARE HORRIBLE!!! Anyone get that already? Bak kata member sorang...cam cheap polyphonic ringtones. (matilah mencarut sampai ke sana!)

And the magic question for the moment is. Berapa lama lagi nak bagi peluang kat Aswad?
Again...this is the WORST Akademi Fantasia concert in the history of the show.
Please...everyone...if you love the show...add your comments below and tell these people how horrible it is....do it at least for me for having to be in the damn Dewan Sivik and that I don't have to be tortured watching it...arghhh!!!!!!!

Bahan bacaan lain :
Mr Manager
Juan Danza
Budiey
Ajami

	marina June 14, 2007   10:33 PM PDT   hai, saye x pernah tgk AF before ni pun n x suke pun AF dari dulu lagi...but lately lepas surf net bosan2,tgk la AF5...ternyata saye jadi melekat tgk AF5 ni krena saye nak tgk aznil hj nawawi...im a big fan of him!!! i want to see him sing in af konsert, i want to see him do the talking in the show rather than tgk student af nyanyi yg x sedap langsung tu...maybe ramai kate af5 xbest becoz dah boring dgn af 1,2,3,4 yg konsep die same je. anyway aznil hj nawawi is the best,becoz of him,af is alive!

	dek April 13, 2007   04:18 AM PDT   ei aku ada byk lagi sambungan gambo tu. mase die kat genting pon ada!! http://www.clickshop2u.com

	keypad April 4, 2007   10:21 AM PDT   ni lagi hampeh punya AF....xda pedoman langsung.....musik mcm rekod dari tandas awam,bunyi drum mcm bunyi kotak.....Roslan Aziz,hang P letak Jawatan laaaa..jadi pengetua tadika lagi ok

	dingdong March 25, 2007   02:14 AM PDT   alioww...aku da a x penah minat af...tp dgr lagu af musim ni....aduih mak...thp cincai tau tk...cincai HANCUS.... adehh dafi tu arap muke jew[mmg la kiut KOT]...sore xda a bgs sgt...nyanyi uptown girl dgr mcm ok sbb dia pronounce dgn elok jew....kalau mcm tu je performance dia...x ya a... aku rasa syawal ok la...suka sore dia...br jantan sikit..heuhehe.... heliza bwk lagu fav ku...boleh la...bak kate OGY 'there are sometimes that you capture the moment , kire gwa ku d robek a..' heuhueuhe rizal ..mamat keras,kayu.ketat..stiff thp babuns punye...da a bwk lagu fav aku.....ohh tidaakkkk!!! aizat..bdk2 nyanyi....tp he's havin fun at least..ntah a bdk ni ebi..woi daku suke rambutnye..heuhuheuh...ok wat....tp nyanyi pn mcm org tgh kena kancing giegiey sajer...heuuhe lain mls nk komen...x bgs pn music mlm tu xya citer a....lebih teruk dr prom night punye sound system...lg menambahkn keSUMBANgan mereka2 itu....adeeh

	dingdong March 25, 2007   02:14 AM PDT   alioww...aku da a x penah minat af...tp dgr lagu af musim ni....aduih mak...thp cincai tau tk...cincai HANCUS.... adehh dafi tu arap muke jew[mmg la kiut KOT]...sore xda a bgs sgt...nyanyi uptown girl dgr mcm ok sbb dia pronounce dgn elok jew....kalau mcm tu je performance dia...x ya a... aku rasa syawal ok la...suka sore dia...br jantan sikit..heuhehe.... heliza bwk lagu fav ku...boleh la...bak kate OGY 'there are sometimes that you capture the moment , kire gwa ku d robek a..' heuhueuhe rizal ..mamat keras,kayu.ketat..stiff thp babuns punye...da a bwk lagu fav aku.....ohh tidaakkkk!!! aizat..bdk2 nyanyi....tp he's havin fun at least..ntah a bdk ni ebi..woi daku suke rambutnye..heuhuheuh...ok wat....tp nyanyi pn mcm org tgh kena kancing giegiey sajer...heuuhe lain mls nk komen...x bgs pn music mlm tu xya citer a....lebih teruk dr prom night punye sound system...lg menambahkn keSUMBANgan mereka2 itu....adeeh

	shiroutt March 21, 2007   10:40 PM PDT   betul tu... aku pun rasa af5 is the worse af ever.. and i think astro should stop af after af5.. cos i think af will be the most boring programme in astro.. and if 2nd concert still like 1st concert,they all should go home and don't do any other concert more.. buang duit dan masa je...

	Nameniza March 21, 2007   07:29 PM PDT   aku memang x tahan dgn dak dekna tu...alah kalau nk di katekan sume girl dlm tu aku benci!!!!!!tapi heliza tu boleh tahan la coz x gediksss mcm yg lain!!!setuju x?????

	azamsky March 21, 2007   03:06 PM PDT   Allo sume. Aku pun tak tau nak komen macamana lagi. korang dah menyatakan hasrat hati aku. Tapi aku nak cakap sikitla Aku paling tak suka bebudak pempuan yang menggedik gial. Mentang2 lah ada kamera. masing-masing tunjuk perangai. Bergelek2. Eleh..orang sume dah tau lah yang korang nak pancing undi. Tak payahlah..BE YOURSELF!! Budak lelaki pun satu. Macam hampeh. Perasan bagus.relaxlah bro. lu orang umur dah besarkan. jangan lah poyo gila.. apapun..AKU SUKA CIKGU LINDA JASMIN..HEHEHEHE

	azamsky March 21, 2007   03:05 PM PDT   Allo sume. Aku pun tak tau nak komen macamana lagi. korang dah menyatakan hasrat hati aku. Tapi aku nak cakap sikitla Aku paling tak suka bebudak pempuan yang menggedik gial. Mentang2 lah ada kamera. masing-masing tunjuk perangai. Bergelek2. Eleh..orang sume dah tau lah yang korang nak pancing undi. Tak payahlah..BE YOURSELF!! Budak lelaki pun satu. Macam hampeh. Perasan bagus.relaxlah bro. lu orang umur dah besarkan. jangan lah poyo gila.. apapun..AKU SUKA CIKGU LINDA JASMIN..HEHEHEHE

	azamsky March 21, 2007   03:05 PM PDT   Allo sume. Aku pun tak tau nak komen macamana lagi. korang dah menyatakan hasrat hati aku. Tapi aku nak cakap sikitla Aku paling tak suka bebudak pempuan yang menggedik gial. Mentang2 lah ada kamera. masing-masing tunjuk perangai. Bergelek2. Eleh..orang sume dah tau lah yang korang nak pancing undi. Tak payahlah..BE YOURSELF!! Budak lelaki pun satu. Macam hampeh. Perasan bagus.relaxlah bro. lu orang umur dah besarkan. jangan lah poyo gila.. apapun..AKU SUKA CIKGU LINDA JASMIN..HEHEHEHE

	Viera March 21, 2007   02:49 PM PDT   KK agreed!HORRIBLE!

	MsGaban March 20, 2007   05:32 PM PDT   never before i tertidur during af concert. by the 3rd student punya performance i was already snoring my heart out. dorang ke the best among the best? seriously? seriously? SERIOUSLY????

	OAZY March 20, 2007   05:15 PM PDT   jOE, "Why was she dressed cam katil Dekna lak ngan ropol ropol whatever frills yang pink tuh. Aiyo!! " THIS IS HILLARIOUS MAN! GOOD JOB! REALLY ENJOY READING YOUR COMMENT!

	klubbkidd March 20, 2007   03:17 PM PDT   ah ah...dafi is nana punya forummer.tau...hiks.nothing personal against that boy but he is just SO average

	Ann March 20, 2007   02:05 PM PDT   Like my friend said before concert, malas nak gi coz we reckon half of them would suck...little did we know that practically all of them sucked big time! (except for Heliza). U're right on all counts my dear - this is the WORST AF by far and the arrangement???? Indescribably bad - even to my amateur ears! So Joe dear, my sympathies for having to endure it all over again this Saturday...! hehe P/S: Btw, Dafi is Nana's fan

	Ieja March 20, 2007   10:31 AM PDT   Ermmm.. bosan. *yawns*

	luvsushi March 20, 2007   10:11 AM PDT   I agree with most of the comments above. KEKESALAN YANG AMAT SANGAT! Budak2 AF5 ni sebenarnya, tak boleh diberi muka minggu ni. Jangan terlalu memuji, kadang-kala harus mengeji supaya tak lupa diri!Kena 'ajar' sikit diorang nih supaya BANGUN DARI ALAM FANTASI - obviously they believe they are the CREAM, dah cukup bagus dapat masuk AF5. Most of them main je yang lebih - sibuk dgn kamera! Tak cukup dengan tu...terkinja-kinja, tergedik-gedik, terhegeh-hegeh, perasan bagus (and the list goes on and on and on...). However, a pinch of good points to heliza and syawal. Heliza has charisma, intelligent and has good communication wise (her personality topped her singing tho); Syawal has strong voice and he seems lively. Noni...has potential (voice and physical looks) but has to get rid of her 'gedikness'. Deqna? Berpotensi but i just can't stand her personality. puhleezzz....camni ke nak jadi artis berwibawa? she'd better be informed about her 'gedikness' too. Penat tgk gelagat budak2 ni...kalau dulu2, 8.30pm je terpacak depan tv, nowadays...dah malas nak tgk diary....sakit hati! Never in history of AF i rasa kesal macam ni. I believe ramai antara kita adalah pengikut setia AF dari musim pertama. After 4 years, things should be better not WORSE!Seteruk-teruk AF4 rupanya teruk lagi AF5 ni. The worst AF concert ever and i can't imagine myself being one of the audience kat Dewan Sivik mlm tu - malu! tak tau mana nak sorok muka and tutup telinga. REALLY, REALLY DISSAPOINT ME! I do undertand, RA must have his own vision and mission but apparently tak terlaksana dlm konsert yang lepas. All the so called 'kezutan' didn't affect me at all. naik menyampah dgn all the kezutan. Aswad and Fatin? mmm...at first i thot it's ok to give them a chance, but now i think it's better to KICK THEM OUT from the academy. Nothing special! They can just come back next year and who knows if tuah menyebelahi mereka they'll get their second chance! Hope things will improve soon or else i angkat kaki...no more AF for me. I'm currently tuning in to Gangstarz and obviously the contestants are wayyyy much, much more better than those clowns on Dewan Sivik stage last week. Mu conclusion - The WORST 1st concert ever in AF history! AF production team....u guys need to do a lot of work!

	ewan March 20, 2007   09:27 AM PDT   Let's just turn to TV3 for the Gangstarz and find a more pleasant thing to do on our precious Saturday nights. AF5 is just soooooooo not worth it.

	ewan March 20, 2007   03:04 AM PDT   I'm switching over to gangstarz. They are more talented and really do show effort. Plus the show is straightforward and critiques are no nonsense.

	ewan March 20, 2007   03:04 AM PDT   I'm switching over to gangstarz. They are more talented and really do show effort. Plus the show is straightforward and critiques are no nonsense.

	Suci March 19, 2007   11:14 PM PDT   aler keris, i think ogy sangat geram..so that was why she shouted to those kids on that nite. she din have to crave for the audience's attention i guess,since she's a household name already..and she did her homework by knowing the essence of the songs which were sung by the kids. what irked me most was of coz none other than Jee. Her comments were forgettable. the tutup telinga adalah from the anugerah berita harian kot.

	kakakdegil March 19, 2007   10:34 PM PDT   aik..layan jugak ke? hahaha.. ingat tak layan.. so saja laa nak kongsi jugak.. wakaaaa.. malewwwww jer..

	kaklady March 19, 2007   10:00 PM PDT   Akak nak komen kat sini pulak...bior pihak Astro sedar betapa teroknnya konsert hari tu...hampeh...teruk macam nak mampooooossss....suara pelajar diorang tu lebih sedap bebudak tadika kalau nyanyi...tu lah kak lady tengok dlm diari...diorang tu lebih memain...masa dpt tawaran macam nak giler sukanya...tapi bila dah kat akademi syok sendiri pulak.....malas dah nak cakap aper2...walau camaner pun Heliza tu boleh lah diharap...yang lain cam siut.... Seb baik ade Ogy yang bagi diorang tu sedar diri...& suka sgt kat komen Ogy...dan itulah sebab utama kak lady nak tengok the next concert...nak tengok bebudak ni ade perubahan tak...atau masih lagi perasan bagus....

	JBJ March 19, 2007   09:29 PM PDT   Kalau si Aswad tu tak nyani lagi minggu ni, Astro jgn pandai2 tunjuk video clip cam ari tu. Kick him out je.. mengabihkan bogheh jo. Pengundi pun satu, yg mengundi Aswad tu wat pe? @#$$% betul.

	pulut March 19, 2007   07:26 PM PDT   uuhhh...uhhhh...Zana Gone Wild...(stroking my 'beast')

	Kak Jah March 19, 2007   06:17 PM PDT   Ni le akibatnya bayar si RA tu lebih2 sampai Astro x ckp duit nak hire live musician. Tmpt tinggal bebudak AF pun dah makin low standard terutama bilik bebudak laki....... Yg ptt kena maki sebenarnya Astro lah, dah lah kita bayar langganan, iklan pulak berlambak2 tp buat production makin low class camni.... AF5 hampeh!

	DariSeberang March 19, 2007   05:08 PM PDT   Rasanya masalah paling besar, adalah music arrangement yg bercelaru..Tak best langsung bunyi nya..

	kayizwan March 19, 2007   03:13 PM PDT   lagu menuju puncak tu dah macam lagu menuju belukar jer... overall, performance konsert pertama AF5 dah di downgradekan oleh mereka yg perasan yg mereka ni bagus bagus belaka...

	y March 19, 2007   02:18 PM PDT   haha mmg music yg jadi sebab utama konsert hampeh. utk yg terlepas tu, aku ada upload audio dia kat blog aku. so dengar la dgn telinga sendiri. but be warned, music dia keji sgt!

	Ann68 March 19, 2007   01:33 PM PDT   Hi Joe, Frankly with all the comments and rantings spilled at almost every AF's blog..am not surprised if all of it falls on deaf ears!!!!...Pathethic huh!!!..keji tau...whatever it is, I sincerely hope to see something better this week....esp lagu Menuju Puncak...i don't care how professional or how he is...I want the good old song back...Perioddddd!!!!!

	RAMBO March 19, 2007   01:31 PM PDT   AF5 nih...dah kategori 999.999 skala ricther...dah tahap hancussss....0.001 je....bagi pada aznil ok.... Semuanya sebab susunan music yg plaing hampeh dalam sejarah AF.... Bak kata susunan lagu menuju puncak utk AF5 pun dah tahap ampehh...camne nak jadikan budak2 ni lebih umphhh... Bila susunan music ada umphhh...baru la konsert HIDUP... masa tu terpulang pada BUdak2 tu nye performance..... Baru lahhh tau sape yg betul2 hampeh.... Pangarah music paling HORRIBLE dalam sejarah AF,,,,,,

	payad March 19, 2007   01:02 PM PDT   sorry aku ter letak kat chat box..ni aku bubuh sini -aku rasa yg kat dewan nak gak puaskan ati meke tepok tgn...tapi bila korg igt balik..eh..bukan si minah AF1 awek si khai ni nyanyi better tapi x kemane ke(tapi heliza ni memg akan disukai makcik2 kan) payad » Saba je tunggu dak2 tue perform..1..adoi..2..iskkk..3..bila nak kua yg bes ni..4..wei..ape ni...last..heliza..ok la.n yg klaka..sume jerit cam bes gile je heliza ni nyanyi(aku tgk kat tv) payad » bile dengar music arrangement malam tuh...nak menangis...apesal busuk giler!!igt bila roslan aziz in charge sume will be world class ke ape...aiyokk!sakit hati je.. what astro shud do 1)ketuk pala roslan aziz and bilang -ko jgn bagi statement berdentum dentum kat media pastu students ko berdentumdentum busuknya ~sengal! 2)minus one pon jgn la bangang sgt bunyinya.apsal x ada logika cam bangang??argkhhh!!! 3)bawak balik sham kamikaze! 4)pelik..apsal sorg pon x buat penghayatan lirik...MUSTAHIL...cikgu fetty x ajar..ke diorg yg pemalas dan pemalas..dan pemals...cam dekna..(aku jarang dapat tgk diary..kul 9mlm ulang 12.30pm esoknya??aku x paham..apsal x nak wat macam dulu je) 5)DR ashari(camni eh eeja name die)..apekata die bagi motivation yg keras sikit.(cth : noni..tolong jgn potong ckp org lain..tunggu diorg abis ckp baru ko smbg...2- afiq...jgn igt ko hensem sebab ko x la hensem sgt...3-dekna..ko jgn la poyo ko tu slumberrrr bagai tapi sebenanya ko nih bebal2 ayam..<<<ini adalah contoh..sila guna bahasa yg lebih indah)dak2 ni umor sume 18 keatas x kan nak manja sgt.. 6)bagi la lagu yg bole dak2 ni deliver..memang la nak suruh diorg belajar tapi 1 concert dah macam neraka je..yg 2nd biarlah kami2 yg dok bayo astro setiap bulan...n mak aku dah sebok undi haliza ni enjoy tgk concert..sekali jeeeerr..x kan la kedekut sgt...bukan sume yg tgk concert nih musician ke...artis ke...ramai yg macam mak aku..nak tgk...relax ...enjoy...UNDI!!!so sila tunaikan hasrat meka2 ni SEKALI SEKALA. 7)Fashion show tuh macam bangang.kalau dah bagi baju cantek2 mase fashion show..apsal mase performed baju macam taik?x paham~ 8)Diary kali ni sengal~ walaupon aku jarang tgk diary tapi cam nak pengsan tgk diary ahad baru nak tunjuk syawal sakit tekak!tepok dahi sume!!!concert dah abissssla...kesian budak tue...kalau x...bole dapat undi simpati cam ASWAD tau!!!x adil!!!mentang2 syawal muke die x cam mawi<<<ade kait ke..ekekeke 9)astro...kerah segala tenaga..idea kudrat korg..bukan buat ikut certain2 ppl ckap ape...follow..carikla idea2 lain yg bole diguna pakai...(n pk...majoriti yg tgk AF sape..walaupon korg nak naikkan mutu student korang tapi jgn la wat at the end of the day..sumenye hazabbbbb-p/s:kalau betul pasal mutu:awal2 amik la yg sore gila2 sedap,personaliti...muke letak jauh2) 10)make them sing betterrr...x kira nak bagi penampor bape kali yg penting better.kalau tak ko buang la 5 org sekaligus...GILER KEZUTAN KAN..

	FaRHaNROXx March 19, 2007   12:21 PM PDT   guracus << kalau nak carik pun plsss laa carik orang lain.. takde orang lain ker nak panggil "KAK MAH GALI" tu? eeiii sendiri cakap sendiri gelak..sendiri berangan. dah ler bebudak ni "BOSAN" ko nak tambah dengan kak mah gali yang dah terlebih bosan... Fail Sulit Jarang2 aku tgk pasal KAK MAH GALI yang feeling2 pengacara no2 malaysia tu -.- hampeshh.. Aznil satu2nyer pengacara yang aku rasa dapat selamatkan keadaan even kadang2 dia terover interframe -.-"

	sphinx March 19, 2007   11:53 AM PDT   Ok, nak komen ni. Rasanya masalah paling besar, bagi i lar, adalah music arrangement sebab tak best langsung. I bukan org seni, tak tau muzik but I love music, I love good music and somehow konsert kelmarin music dia busuk giler. Waktu budak2 tu nyanyi, muzik dia lain dari lagu asal, ok takpe lagi, ye lar nak buat kelainan kan tapi bila itu En Roslan tukar Menuju Puncak, aduh terus berderau darah nih!!! Mana boleh, Menuju Puncak tu kan lagu sekolah yang gatal2 pi tukar buat pe???!! Sound system pun cam tak best, production pun cam kelam kabut (waktu tunjuk undi tuh, waktu pengenalan pelajar, waktu elimination students), they need a proper planning or a better idea! Seriously, kalau mcm ni standard AF sekarang kan, baik bagi kat budak2 mass comm kat kolej aku nih, for sure lg meletop dia org leh wat!! Akhir kata, AF 5 Hampeh!!

	topMAN85 March 19, 2007   11:50 AM PDT   JOE ALL THAT PRODUCTION YG PLANNING, DIA ORANG NAK BUAT DUIT LEBIH BUT PADA MASA YG SAMA BERPURA-PURA KATA UNTUK MENCARI BAKAT LAH, MENGASAH BAKAT STUDENT (WHATEVER). BAGI AKU SEMUA NIE BERPUNCA DARI PIHAK ASTRO. SEBELUM TERLUPA ABG AZNIL, ABG HATTAN AND KAK OGY LAKUKAN KEJA MEREKA DGN BAIK.

	tanty March 19, 2007   11:45 AM PDT   if only people like farhan, amylea, zarina, rosma, kaer, yazer were chosen in this af5, i bet it will be great. too bad they were in the earlier groups and lost their battle, but at least winners frm previous af were great too. i really thought af4 was the worst but rupenya af5 yg lebih layak for the title. mmg banyak kezutan. mmg aku sefamily terkejut that none of them are good. heliza yg boleh tahan tu kalau compare in the other af i rasa setakat level zarina and nurul je. audition raja lawak is much a successful compare to af5 nye 1st concert. 1st concert should be the best in every af season. i can't imagine what more surprises will they do in the coming 2nd concert.

	contest.in.motion March 19, 2007   11:20 AM PDT   nak tanya sikit...(mungkin dah di explain tapi mungkin saya ter-miss)..ngapa AF5 ada 3 org pengkritik tetap...boringlah, asyik2 muka yg sama...pengkritik2 yg different each week boleh menonjolkan sikit element keseronakan, kesuspenan..lagipun lain2 orang lain2 cara mengkritik, making it more interesting...ni asyik2 muka sama....

	kak sya March 19, 2007   11:10 AM PDT   Joe I read this blog daily but first time decided to comment.. I 200% agreed with all ur comments.. betul betul busuk and mcm *&^%$ aje Eh please tell Aznil jangan end up jadi cam Azwan Ali.. nanti menyemak TV aje

	keris March 19, 2007   10:53 AM PDT   Am I the only person who thinks that Ogy is trying to promote herself? Telling the students of their faults is one thing, but shouting like that, sooooooo OTT. As for the other two pengkritik?? I'not gonna bother...so I guess no more guest pengkritik like Hetty Koes Endang, who can bring different views and inputs. And Aznil's comment about 'TTTT - (tak bole terima, tutup telinga)'??? what was that about?? ni rancangan utk penonton ke rancangan syok sendiri??, Am I not paying Astro 'monthly' to watch this sorry excuse for a production self indulge ITSELF??? ;- nuff rant for the moment atleast

	guracus March 19, 2007   10:25 AM PDT   Aznil is starting to be a pain in the neck. His antics are getting on my nerves and he is more of a bore than anything else nowadays. He is trying to upstage every students with his stale antics. I honestly believe that aznil thinks this is his programme and every week he gets to strut his stupid antics. AF should have taken a new face. Sarimah would have been a BIG and GOOD change!

	Mier March 19, 2007   09:46 AM PDT   Joe.. akak agreed sungguh dgn apa yg ko kata.. x perlu la nak ulas apa yg ko dah ulas,.... yg nak jadi rock x jadi tu aduh sungguh memalukan... paling aku geram bila derang spoilkan lagu2 yg aku minat terutama milik siapakah gadis ini.. so flat.. x de energy sakit hati tengok... and about gee... dia x perlu ada kat kerusi pengkritik.. dia nyanyi pun la ni flat & masuk laut dalam.. ni af bukan mi .. astro please take note.. we want to see af back no another mi recycle.

	joejoe March 19, 2007   09:15 AM PDT   I see box....ya box.......yes REDBOX.... now I know why AF change the colour to red.... and now we're seeing RED!!!

	Laila March 19, 2007   08:55 AM PDT   Aku sukung ko 100% joe...walaupun aku tgk sekejap2 jer, tgk sambil layan anak tp konsert AF kali mmg teruk laaa...yg aku x paham tu, mesti ke nak buat pesen show atas pentas tuh? Nak promote baju ker? Kesimpulannya, x rasa rugi kalau ada sesaper ketinggalan tgk AF kali ni...kalau nak tgk sgt, leh refer kat youtube......

	angelicbug March 19, 2007   08:55 AM PDT   I wasted 3 hours of my Saturday night watching 13 "students" embarrassed themselves on national TV. It was so bad I had to run to the other room. I pula yang rasa malu tgk they all perform mcm tu. Yes yes, the music was horrible too.

	Anne March 19, 2007   07:10 AM PDT   Joe, can it get anyworse than this....dissapointed gila. And i thot AF4 was bad. Agree with you totally, tapi malas nak repeat la what you have sd. And you know what else is missing....the kids sitting down with Aznil for a short chat...memang ada ramai takde masa, but if they kids do their Afundi promo at the beginning as usual (instead of pertandingan fesyen dak tadika) then at least Aznil leh talk to them...break some monotony. Masa tengok konsert cant help but wonder -this is their best pick of all that came to audition???? - didnt cikgu syafi, adnan, fati teach them anything... dah malas cakap la joe....kita follow since 1st season memang "sayang" la kat AF which makes it the more dissapointing

	Izie March 19, 2007   06:12 AM PDT   Seronok baca review Joe. Memang aku setuju 100% dgn point2 di atas. Aku satu family pon tak setuju dgn pemilihan Jee sebagai pengkritik tetap, takde impak lgsg komen2 dia! setakat komen mata cantik,muka ensem tu perlu ke dijemput? Aku setuju dgn komen Joe supaya pngkritik tetap cuma 2 org je. Yg satu lagi spot tu boleh beri utk pngkritik jemputan, aku harap sangat Adlin akan dijemput balik :/ Satu lagi benda yg aku perasan semalam(dan musim2 lepas gak) pakaian penari2 terlalu seksi! Malu sangat rasa sbb aku tgk tv satu family. Penari uptown girl & lagu kaching tu aku tgk dah mcm tuuut aje rupanya. Dahlah baju sleevless dok angkat2 lagi ketiak tu nak tunjuk ke org. Aku kat rumah yg rasa segan. Tolongla bagi baju yg sopan sikit next time

	ajami March 19, 2007   03:20 AM PDT   hayoo! mr.manager jugek sudeh terguna-pakai perkataan 'busuk' kat gangstarz tadi!.. haruslah jadi perkataan rasmi realiti-tv katanyaaa!.. larikkk!

	klubbkidd March 19, 2007   01:50 AM PDT   kakakdegil : bukan e tu deskripsi vip.jiwang.cc ...hihihihi

	4gotmynick March 19, 2007   01:40 AM PDT   ala.. why so boring this season.. semua pun takde semangat meh.. rasa cam nak suruh je senior2 AF kat bawah pentas tu naik meriahkan suasana yang suram adik2 af5 atas tu.. music macam kenduri kawin memang ye pun.. ntah2 kenduri kawin lagi gempak kot..

	kakakdegil March 19, 2007   01:34 AM PDT   my 2cents: ni pandangan kd untuk konsert minggu pertama.. tune aper kelencut tu kd takkan komen laaa.. Aizat (pengiran cinta - dewa) - Boleh nampak cam penat sket.. tapi still boleh di cover up - Tak nampak pun cam lagu rock.. - Tak tentu hala.. cam takder arah tuju Afiq (janjiku - sofaz) - Sebijik cam sessi berkaraoke.. - Takde apa apa momentum tu kire cam takder spark pun show dia ni - Gaya jer ok.. Mila (bersamamu - Siti sarah) - Flat jer sore dia ni.. - Mimik muka pun kureng.. cam tengah takder perasaan - Certain part sore dia keluar sengau.. auuuu - Start sini aku cam bleh detect music arrangement cam tahik ! Dafi (uptown girl) - Lucky for him dapat lagu macam ni.. - English memang ok siap kita leh dengar dia sebut perkataan tu.. - certain part mic placement cam tak kene.. asyek duk tengok pmpuan tetek leper tu kut? Diya (aku masih setia - dia fadila) - Tak tau mana salahnyer tp cam ada lack of something dalam performance dia ni.. - Suara dia cam terlampau di controlled.. Farha (balada pemuzik jalanan - search) - First sekali, terserlah ke'poser'an dia jadik mamat rock - Memang tak menjadik laa kire.. Sedih aku sebab aku suka lagu ni sesangat.. phewwwittttt Ebi (milik siapakah - sudirman) - Aku tengok how dia dengan penuh kompius.. - Kompius sampai aku tak tau camner org bleh pilih dia ni - Tapi sore dia bleh tahan.. - Ada slanga 't' sket.. Dekna (tanpamu - farawahida) - Lagu ni bagi aku ngam ngan sore dia - Showmanship bleh tahan.. lagi ngam kalau dia nyanyi dengan sepenuh jiwa dan raga Shawal (harapan - fazli zainal) - Dia ada tekak bernanah so aku raser cam kesian jer.. - Sore memang hensem.. tp buleh nampak laa kater tekak dia sakit.. sebab sore dia cam ada ek uk sket.. - Music arrangement yang ni pun kiok Candy (ka ching - shania twain - Starting memuler cam nampak hambar je.. - Tapi macuk chorus walaupun certain perkataan dia cam tengah mumbling jer..tapi dia still tunjukkan good perfomance. - Aper hal ngan kostum cacat tu? Rizal (menanti sebuah jawapan - padi) - Memang time dia nyanyi kita cam boleh layan jer tengok.. - Sore flat .. cam nampak muke bersusah payah tapi sore flat jer? Noni (tak ada logika - agnes monica) - Music arrangement pun out - Show ok.. energy power sebab nyanyi sambil menari ngan rancak - Kain aper kaler pink tu? Cam perca Heliza (kau pergi jua - adam ahmad) - selalu kiter dengar lagu ni memang laki yang nyanyi, so i'm expecting some big voice yg husky gitu tapi ternyata heliza berjaya membawa lagu ni ngan sore yang lembuttapi still full of energy.. bravo - saper reka kostum bodo ni? - part dia tukar melodi tu memang masyuk sangat.. lebih sesuwei ngan dia.. penutup (nyanyian lagu menuju puncak) - berteraburnyer.. rasanyer diorangni cam lack of concentration sesangat - noni cam terlebih goyang sampai lari step fatin kuar menyanyikan lagu angkat kaki yang macam macam penyanyi jemputan lagaknya .. aper motif? kalau nak kuarantinkan, janganla bawak kuar terus. ini siap nyanyi bleh joget joget. wonder berapa ramai orang berjangkit penyakit dia tu eh? diya menjadi pelajar pertama yang terkeluar.. astro bodo tuli .. buat kejutan yang macam tu. di suruhnyer diya duk menunggu kat tangga n aznil announced that ada good news for diya. rupenyer nak kuarkan lagi sorang. called ebi n mila to get in front but then tetiber muncul zana menangis nak tarik diri sebab tekanan kat akademi. setau aku.. kat situ laaa besh. bukan ko kene tekan bebetul pun.. ke ader sebab lain si zana ni ? jeng jeng jengggg.. still si diya tu duk tepi tangga je.. cam org bodo. mende ni? kejutan yang bepatutan laa.. kalau aku jadik diya.. aku chiow jer... conclusionnyer, ni laaa konsert yang takder tinggalkan aper aper kesan kat sanubariku ini.. cewah ! music arrangement cam kepala hotak dia jer. semua lagu cam jadik hambar ! please laa roslan.. syarat nak suh astro lantik berdegam degum.. ayat besar besar dlm tv.. nak buat kelainan lah! aper kelainan tu? dari segi music arrangement? loser betul dia ni..

	harman March 19, 2007   01:28 AM PDT   Joe...........couldn't agree with u more...

	bonchitz March 19, 2007   01:02 AM PDT   ya!!!! 100% setuju!!! music?..hmmm, bonchitz dengar bunyi ketak-ketuk-ketak-ketuk dari awal konsert sampai la ke hujung..diselang-seli dengan nada sengau, flat & lain-lain sepusat sepusing dgn sore mcm loji!! kah.kah.kah. Dengar jek nama pengetua baru AF5..mmg dah agak dahh konsert akan jadi mcm gini! 'stoned' semacammmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm!! cess!! kalau 2nd konsert pun mcm gini nada & irama & melodi... yg terus siaran langsung hampeh..Jgn haraplahh nak hotlink bersama af lagi, baik dok dlm hot tub dgr itik nila mengawan!! ciou!

	afvirgo March 19, 2007   12:40 AM PDT   Music arrangement mmg hampeh!! Yux!!! Pleaselah bring back Sham..se'menyampah'nye org tgk die last season, at least dia x rosakkan lagu... Menuju Puncak pun hampeh!!! Sapalah yg bengap sangat gi tukar..hilang semangat AF...Bring back the original Menuju Puncak! Agree yg Fauziah Latiff tu x perlu..kekalkan Hattan n Kak Ogy..tempat Jee tu boleh dibagi kat pengkritik jemputan mcm season AF yg lalu...nanti bolehlah tgk artis lain get involved with AF walaupun as pengkritik... X suke kalau budak2 tu terus hantar balik kampung...So MEAN (walaupun student kali ni memang layak pun nak dikejam2kan)..hilang semangat family AF camni..nampak lebih elok kalau diorang ader tengok konsert tiap2 minggu.. Should let the teachers do their job as they like...jgnlah ikut kata Roslan Aziz yg perasan 'abang' tu..the teachers lebih experienced dari RA bab AF ni... Xde triggers last concert mcm x berapa best sngt..x rasa mcm AF..rasa cam realiti show lain.. Ish..pleaselah bring the old AF back...nak buat pembaharuan tu berpada2lah...don't make me HATE the show...I've been a fan since the Tirai first Season...I don't want to stop now...Please ASTRO do sumthing....

	FaRHaNROXx March 19, 2007   12:25 AM PDT   apa yang boleh saya kata tentang Konsert Pertama Akademi Fantasia 5. 1 word saja.. "BOSAN" *feeling2 jadik mrmanager*. sususan muzik.. macam kat funfair tau.. funfair pun better.. budak2 tu tak belajar kat class ke? menggedik terhegeh2 jer.. nyanyi macam nyanyi kat karaoke la.. haaizz sengal nyer tahap gaban.. tgk dalam diari benda2 yang tak perlu yang dorang buat.. bukan nak berlatih ker aper ker.. banyak giler lagu2 peberet dihancurkan.. haizz sengal sungguh 1more nama jer ada stylist berbagai.. geli tau tgk baju aizat ngan syawal.. tak per lu ok.. kalau macam ni laa cara nyer.. sama jer ngan zaman si YODA tu... so dorang 2 2 ni boleh lagakan dalam satu bilik pastu BOOM kan.. semak.. abiskan duit jer kejutan yang tak berapa nak terkejut atau kita perlu pura2 terkejut -.- sengal tahap gaban.. dan akademi tak perlu lerr nak promo si fatin ngan si aswad tu lebih.. bukan nyer bagus sangat pun... pengkiritik = fauziah latif boleh balik tido.. ada macam takde.. bak kata joe pun.. dia feeling2 paula abdul agaknyer.. nak jadik juri yang ala2 baik gitu.. piii raaa.. apa2 pun Ogy + Aznil rox the house nasib baik ada dorang nie.. kalau takde konsert AF memang bertambah suram+bosan+bebal+magkuk+habiskan beras

	Adren M. March 19, 2007   12:16 AM PDT   Pertama sekali selepas AF4 produksi telah di humban masuk jamban diflush tapi rupanya ada lagi sisa2 di bibir piring putih jubin. Orang punya expectation yang dah expose dengan pelbagai lain realiti show yang lain sangat mengharapkan Akademi akan ubah cara mcm mana ia akan diterbitkan. Penonton bukan lagi hidup di zaman Bintang RTM. Kita nak tgk production show yang mantap dan meletop2. Selepas Sinaran dah lama tak de program mencari bakat selepas Akademi. Sebab tu Akademi mencetus satu lagi fenomena. Dan sebab itu kami orang2 kebanyakkan, penonton2 iklan anda sangat ambil berat dengan Akademi. Pasal bebudak yang menyanyi malam tu malas nak komen la. Sebab lagu diberi bukan dipilih. Kadang2 kalau pilih sendiri pun tak kena. Peraturannya kalau boleh bebudak tu menyanyi semua genre. Kononnya dorang semua bakal menyanyi di kelab malam menghiburkan pakcik2 tua. Kita nak melahirkan penyanyi yang meletop. Kita tak boleh paksa bebudak tu buat semua benda. Kalau kekuatan pada pop well pilih lagu2 pop sahaja. Kalau soul and r&B then jangan bagi lagu dangdut atau lagi asli. Ini bukan soal cabar mencabar tapi soal untuk menjadikan mereka kekal 50 tahun akan datang. Lagi satu bebudak ni bukan dari kecik belajar berzanji dan bermarhaban atau ikut mak bapak pergi menyanyi kat kelab karaoke atau ibonda kepada penyanyi antarabangsa, tapi dorang just hari ini noreh getah esok masuk akademi. Menyanyi setakat suka2 dalam bilik air sambil naik basikal dalam kereta. Sebab itu bila naik pentas memang pertandingan karaoke yang kita nampak. In fact dorang yang masuk pertandingan karaoke pun lagi meletop sebab setengah dari dorang penyanyi kelab malam. Kalau anda keje menyanyi tiap malam mestilah pitch, timing, tempo anda perfect sebab u ols dibayar untuk buat semua tu dengan perfect. Tapi itu standard yang ada kat Malaysia. Setakat itu je. Pikir kita kat Malaysia dan memang kita belom lagi sampai tahap mak ayah anta budak 5 tahun masuk kelas piano dan masuk kelas vokal. Kalau ada pun mak ayah gaji 5 angka sebulan. Apa yang ada adalah bakat semulajadi yang sangat mentah. Dah masuk 20an baru nak belajar tu belajar ni. Gud Luck la semua

	akak kg March 18, 2007   11:19 PM PDT   hi Joe akak pun frust juga tengok AF5. Peserta pun hampeh ditambah susunan muzik yg teruk tu (walaupun akak org kg tapi telinga ni masih lagi sensitif pada bunyi tau). Terkejut beruk juga bila Aznil umum fauziah Latif jadi juri...alamak dia sendiri pun nyanyi ke laut...hancus..

	my$ARAbeLLA March 18, 2007   10:55 PM PDT   worst af concert ever.af4 at least ade laa some SINGERS we look forward to kan.af2 n af3 jauh skali laaa..ini penat tgu smpai kol 12 lbey....soooo damn frustrating

	dewidevina March 18, 2007   10:54 PM PDT   If ASTRO is going to read this, then I'll be as 'polite' as possible. WHAT HAPPENED TO AKADEMI FANTASIA ALREADY?!! Why has it rundown so BAD? What happened since Season 2 and 3? Please change the music arrangements...PLEASE!! It was ultimately boring and unbearable to watch seriously! ASTRO, you really should consider looking at this seriously or you WOULD or WILL be losing your audiences/supporters of AF! I know many people did already this season (actually since the last season!). And you have to be FAIR to every student! Why give Aswad a chance (not being hateful ya!)? Because he wasn't well? How about previous students of AF who were not well but still managed to performed as much as they could? Let's hope the next concert would be GREATER than the previous (and I meant it IN A GOOD SURPRISE!). Please don't 'torture' us with another boring concert!! Bring back the REAL AKADEMI FANTASIA! Thank you. - devinadewi -

	blacko March 18, 2007   10:20 PM PDT   alop joe.. aku pun sokong sejuta peratus ngan komen ko. Paling aku angin skali ngan muzik lah. Sakit ati aku dgr.. anyway pasal aswad tu aku tau mmg tak adil ah sbb die tak perform kan. tp bile aku tgk video klip die, aku still rase suara die lagi ok dr budak laki lain base daripada konsert semalam. Mmg suara camtu dah banyak kat malaysia, tp aku lg sanggup dgr suara klon dari suara cam tah pape, nanyi malas, sumbang ke laut. tp kalau minggu depan die takleh perform gak, mmg patut die kuar gak lah.

	Audra March 18, 2007   09:43 PM PDT   Heyas Joe, I'm very disappointed with the production team of this season's AF. The first concert was the worst ever, even if compared with AF1 (first concert). And somebody should get rid of the camera that the students use to talk to. Plastik sangat!!! Hahaha.. you mentioned Red Box and that was exactly the thing on my mind through out the whole concert.

	nurul March 18, 2007   09:31 PM PDT   i do agree ngn most of ur comments..mmmpp..first bile u mentioned bout that "gedik noni"..hahah..mmg xboleh layan tgk die..gedik tahap cipan!..2) bout that "PoYo"..haha..aku pon nyampah die..perasan smart cm hape jer..inagt die sape..warghhh!! 3) rase nyer mmg lagu menuju puncak this time x "power" cm dulu..xde semangat..music die x best..4) kick ASWAD..even aku ni kira 1 of mawi's fan, and drg ckp die cm mawi..?hah?xde langsong..

	zah March 18, 2007   09:27 PM PDT   konsert yang paling busuk cam haper jerk.Dulu aku nyampah kat dak AF4 tp skarang aku rs dorg lg better dr dak2 AF5 yg cam ampeh tahap longkang.Bongok tul

	Suci March 18, 2007   09:20 PM PDT   most of ur comments i do agree with.. but some, i rasa u r being quite biased to the kids..considering they are quite green u cannot expect them to deliver Juara Lagu- like on their very first concert. deqna is a clown but her presence in the diary can be felt by most of the diary watchers.so clownish as she is,people will still vote for her. and yeah,this one i toooooooootally agree..KICK FATIN n ASWAD out..even diya fared much better than aswad [at least she's pretty not an eyesore to watch..] haha

	kawahapi March 18, 2007   06:05 PM PDT   Joe komen mu x pernah mengecewakan :) Very true sgt membosankan sgt bodoh dan sgt muarahan And YES aznil tu aduhai, tolong la.. ko bisik2 skit la kat dia udah2 la nak over kat stage tu ek?

	miyo March 18, 2007   05:50 PM PDT   If there's 500 million people who watched the concert last night, all 500 million would say that it was the worst AF concert to date. The music arrangements were too horrendous to go unnoticed.

	Pixie March 18, 2007   05:45 PM PDT   Hi Joe, memang betul pun apa yang kau senaraikan nih....Sokong 200%!! Muzik memang horrible tahap jamban! Mcm nih ke hasil kerja pengarah muzik yg bawak siti ke London? Yg jadik leader masa PGL The Musical? Malu gilak!!! P/S: Joe, Dafi tu bekas course mate aku doh....!!! Hehehe...